Analysis of Factors Affecting Women Empowerment in the Development of Bangladesh
Women empowerment plays a pivotal role in the overall development of a country. This study utilizes four dimensions related to women empowerment for calculating an empowerment index, as no specific concept of women empowerment exists in the datasets (BDHS 2017-18 and BDHS 2022). The bivariate analysis was performed to investigate the percentage distribution of the Women Empowerment Index (WEI), constructed with the association of the dimensions, with various covariates. The ANOVA F-test and Pearson Chi-Square test are applied for finding the adjusted association between selected dimensions and covariates in the study years. Covariates with a p-value less than 0.05 in both study years are incorporated in the multivariate regression models. An ordinal logistic regression model was used to determine the adjusted effects of selected covariates on women's empowerment, as the empowerment index is an ordinal response variable. An ordinal probit model was tested to understand the likelihood of the categories being employed in the empowerment of women. Both the models were tested to be a good and adequate fit. Overall, the women empowerment rate has seen a decrease throughout the consecutive study years. Though, the number of less empowered women has decreased, the amount of empowered women has also seen a little bit of downfall in Bangladesh. Some recommendations were specified based on the results for enhancing women empowerment in our country.
Women empowerment refers to the procedure by means of which women acquire the ability to organize themselves in increasing their own self-sufficiency, to declare their independent right in making decisions and to control assets that will support in challenging and eradicating their own dependence (Keller, B., & Mbwewe, D., 1991). It has been specified by considering a multidimensional problem that can be designated by education, occupation, discussion of family planning with partners, decision making inside the household, free movement, marriage age, political representation and legal rights (Alsaawi, M., & Adamchak, D.J., 2000; Al-Riyami, A.A., & Afifi, M., 2003). Many national development plans are increasing their importance in the integration of women towards the development procedure and hence, their involvement in economic activities alongside men (Dixon, R.B., 1978). In order to achieve the targets set up by Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in 2015, which draws attention to guarantee the full and efficient participation of women and equal opportunities in all sectors, women empowerment has been considered as a prerequisite (UNDP, 2016; Molina, 2025).
It is a long-standing matter that in a society with strong patriarchy as Bangladesh, women are assigned a lower status as men who have the absolute power of administering households and society as a whole, whilst women are quite often confined to household duties (Balk, D., 1997). Bangladesh has made huge progression towards the workforce participation of women. The industrial sector, especially the apparel industry and services sector fueled the higher growth in the workforce participation of women though the most number of women are recruited in the agriculture sector. Women are becoming more engaged about their career than before in these times (Islam, N., & Khatun, J., 2019). However, the overall national rate is still too low and the rate falls behind the rate for male counterparts to a large extent in Bangladesh (Kokitula et al., 2019; Pomi, 2021).
Education can be considered the factor that assume more power or autonomy for women in our country (Paul et al., 2016). However, a large section of the Bangladeshi women are illiterate or low-educated. They rely heavily on their father or husband for fulfilling their needs. Because of this dependence, they have no choice but to follow decisions of their father or husband (Tabassum et al., 2019). Even after completing their education, a large number of women have been choosing to be homemaker. (Mahmood, F., & Rezina, S., 2016). Even though women's workforce participation is increasing, Lack of job opportunities is still apparent widely in rural areas despite that the participation of women in the workforce is increasing. (Kalam, I.M.S., & Amin, M.M.A., 2016).
It has been found that organizations having a greater number of women involved in the leadership roles perform better than organizations having lesser women in the leadership roles (Tyagi, S., 2015). However, women's participation in leadership/managerial positions has consistently been under the radar than men in these economically in dispensible industries of Bangladesh (Islam et al., 2017). Women become unproductive counterparts in society because of lack of financial independence, which also minimize the opportunities for them to contribute to economic development (Niaz, M.U., & Iqbal, M., 2019). Tradi-tionally, geographic mobility has been remarkably limited of the poor women in the rural sides of Bangladesh. Effective restriction of mobility for women is fairly severe today in many scenarios (Islam, N., & Khatun, J., 2019).
Some of the major reasons for women for not partaking in the workforce are domestic responsebilities, family-specific roles and commitments to their community. Work-family disputes are commonly ascribed to the fewer number of women in the workforce (Salleh, S.N.S., & Mansor, N., 2022). Becoming a parent is associated with a change to more traditional gender roles, with men expanding their involvement in the workforce and women reducing their participation in the workforce (Abroms, L.C., & Goldscheider, F.K., 2002; Baxter et al., 2008; Christie-Mizell, C., 2006; Gjerdingen, D.K., & Center, B.A., 2005; Sanchez, L., & Thomson, E., 1997).
Another major constraint on women's workforce participation have been identified in the form of long standing health issues among women (Majeed et al., 2014; Pit, S.W., & Byles, J., 2012). Apart from all of these, cultural barriers, gender discrimination, social hazard, physical challenges and lack of family support makes it worse for working women to continue their jobs (Mahmood, F., & Sonia, R., 2016). In comparison to the last decades, even though women empowerment rate has increased in Bangladesh, but it is still quite lower in comparison to the global progress (Islam, N., & Khatun, J., 2019). For a sustainable development of Bangladesh, increasing female employment rate is a must.
Objectives of the study
This study aims to analyze the factors influencing women empowerment, identify barriers and propose strategies to enhance women's participation in Bangladesh, contributing to the advancement of gender equality and overall societal progress. The study is intended to be carried out keeping in view the following objectives:
Women empowerment has been the subject of concern within the policy makers of developing countries, the inclusion of women into the process of uplifting the society and consequently, their partaking in economic activities alongside men, have gained significance in several national and international development plans (Paul et al., 2016). The economic development, empowerment, gender equality and upliftment of society is largely influenced by the participation of women in the workforce (Mehtap et al., 2016). Women's involvement in the workforce not only boosts the economic progression of a country but also other social sectors to expand (Islam, N., & Khatun, J., 2019). Education level, religion, age, place of residence, marital status, family financial status and media coverage are some of the key elements that affects women's the empowerment of women (Haque et al., 2011). As stated by the International Labour Organization, women's participation in the wokforce enhanced by 35 percent between 2008 and 2017 in Bangladesh (Nawaz, F., & Haque, T., 2020). The percentage is following an upward trend since.
Educational is considered as the principal requirement for the empowerment of women in all aspects of the society. The most crucial factor for social change is higher education (Malik, S., & Courtney, K., 2011). According to a study, women's educational attainment is considered more essential than their workforce participation (Hossain et al., 2012). The fact that higher education plays a crucial impact on women empowerment was proven on the basis of results which highlighted that almost 88% of the respondents in the Pakistani society agreed to the fact that women empowerment is amplified by higher education (Razzaq, S., & Mehmood, S.T., 2022).
Literacy rate for women has imposed a positive impact on the ideological, political and social spheres in accordance with a study conducted in the North-Eastern region of India. This region is influenced greatly by positive changes of education and training in achieving this result (Pegu, A., 2015). The opportunity cost of not participating grows along education level, and hence it is suggested that higher education refers to a higher probability in the employment market (Khandker, S.R., 1987). Education has a beneficial influence on female labor force participation of women (Contreas, D, & Plaza, G., 2010; England et al., 2012). Women with higher education degrees are more inclined to participate in labor force in comparison with the other groups (Kotikula et al., 2019). Women as head of the household, with higher education, residence in urban area have played a positive impact on female workforce participation. However, ownership of land, lower level of education, women's marital status, having infants have an adverse impact on the empowerment of women (Rahman, R.I., 2005)
Even though women who received higher education have the highest level of empowerment among other classes, husband's education also plays a crucial role to understand the needs of wife and involving wife in decision making (Haque et al., 2011). A study that observed more than 70 developing countries concluded that Educated women are in a much better position to participate in financial and non-financial decision making in contrast to women who did not attain any formal or technical sector education, according to a study that observed the conditions of women from more than 70 developed countries (Le, K., & Nyugen, M., 2021). When women receives more and more education, an awareness of her rights increases in her which subsequently increases women empowerment (Urooj et al., 2022; Baig et al., 2020; Shetty, S., & Hans, V., 2015). As the level of educa-tion of women and their husband's increases, the status of women empowerment increases simultaneously (Urooj et al., 2022; Islam et al., 2023).
Marriage is considered as a known associate of women workforce participation in Bangladesh (Mahmud, S., & Bidisha, S.H., 2018). Marriage penalizes only urban women's participation in the workforce, while it is associated with a greater probability of workforce participation for men residing in the urban areas, and for both men and women in rural areas, according to a report of the Labor Force Survey (LFS) data in Voices to Choices. Some cases show that marriage imposes a negative effect on the workforce participation of women (Blau et al., 2014; Nor & Said, 2016). Moreover, single/divorced/widowed women leads by 19.3 percent in workforce participation than married women according to a study conducted in Malaysia using the Labour Force Survey data. Married men are more likely to join the workforce than married women because the husband is the main provider for the family (Nor, & Said, 2016). The workforce participation of married women and their age shows an inverted U-shaped pattern. The pattern specifies that the participation of women in the workforce increases initially but decreases later on. Additionally, women who were previously married have a higher probability of participating in the workforce and its percentage increased by 22.3 percent, thus announcing the probability of a push factor among the divorced, separated and widowed women to participate in the workforce in order to survive (Salleh, S.N.S., & Mansor, N., 2022).
Another constraint to women's workforce participation in Bangladesh and other countries is the presence of children, particularly younger than 5 years old (Solotaroff et al., 2019). According to a study conducted using the Fifth Malaysian Population and Family survey (2014), nearly 65 percent of women stated care provision, particularly taking care of their children, is their major reason for not participating in the labour force. Besides, women's participation in the workforce is affected significantly by the number of children (Salleh, S.N.S., & Mansor, N., 2022). An argument emerged that if women are relieved from the weight of childcare and at the same time if they are given opportunity to obtain education from educational institutions, the probabilities of their workforce engagement would enhance significantly (Ejaz et al., 2010; Azam & Rafiq, 2014).
Perceptions and attitudes are heavily interrelated with female workforce participation. Women who consider the outside environment as safe and sound and who are comfortable travelling outside the homes by themselves are 9.6 percentage more likely to participate in the workforce. Women with conservative viewpoint are less likely towards participation in the workforce. Women who state themselves being depressed are 10.5 more likely to be working (Kotikula et al., 2019). Women's labor force participation is also restricted by social and cultural norms (Dildar, Y., 2015). Such norms have narrowed the choice of the labour force participation for women (Heintz et al., 2018; Nazier, H., & Ramadan, R., 2018). Disregarding the encumbrance of unpaid care activities amid working women and how social and cultural norms affect women's ability to enter and remain in the workforce subscribe to the ongoing gender gap in workforce participation (Ferrant et al., 2014).
Though mostly in urban areas, creation of large-scale jobs in the manufacturing sector has been contributing to employment growth. This extension is another factor in the female employment growth that has brought a massive number of women into the workforce (Farole, T., & Cho, Y., 2017). Another constraint on the job accessibility to women is occupational sex-segregation. Gender norms often dictate the concept of “women's work” in Bangladesh that further affect the perceptions formed among people about what is acceptable for men and women (Kotikula et al., 2019). However, a promising trend was shown according to the Labor Force Survey (2016) that many manufacturing and higher skilled occupations displayed a high portion of female workers. Organizations can create their own practices, norms and cultures that are more convenient for female stuff (Hossain, J.B., & Kusakabe, K., 2005). In case of accessing job opportunities, accessibility to transportation is of key significance. Recent researches show that excessive levels of gender-based violence in public transportation and the bordering public spaces in many parts throughout the world is quite visible (Gonzalez et al., 2015). A research by BRAC in Dhaka area suggests that around 94 percent of women have faced any forms of sexual harassment in public transportations whereas 20.5 percent of women stopped using public transportations for these conditions (The Daily Star, 2018). The practice of Purdah and limitation of mobility is speculated to prevent women from searching for beneficial jobs outside their home (Kabeer, N., 2013; Ahmed, T., & Sen, B., 2018; Asadullah, M.N., & Wahhaj, Z., 2019). Moreover, a comparatively low proportion of working women move out of their their community to work (Kotikula et al., 2019).
Another major obstacle in the women workforce participation is the financial status of the families. A woman who belong in a low-earning family are often forced to participate in the workforce because of financial difficulties. Economically sound and wealthy women are less active in the workforce (Azam, A., & Rafiq, M., 2014; Shi, Y. et al., 2016). Moreover, women living in joint families participate in the workforce, surpassing the women living in nuclear families (Azam, A., & Rafiq, M., 2014). Urban women participate more in the workforce than rural women (Hussain et al., 2016; Nor et al., 2014). The workforce participation of women is often not her own choice. As Bangladesh has a strong patriarchal society, such decisions are often dictated or guided by the male members of the family (Kabeer, N., 2013). In reference to leadership competence, women have gained a legitimate space in political organizations that can uplift their marginalized position, even though they still remain a minority (Khan, M.M.R., & Ara, F., 2006). Media exposure is another factor that heavily influence the empowerment of women. Women with media accessibility have higher percentage of workforce participation than those with few or no accessibility to media (Chaudhry, I., & Nosheen, F., 2009; Khan, S.U., & Awan, R., 2011; Nayak, P., & Mahanta, B., 2012; Paul, S., 2016). Education, training and exposure to information media are playing the pivotal role in the empowerment of women in Bangladesh (Parveen et al., 2005).
A diversified scene can be found within the tribal women, where they participate to the family economy positively along with men in subsistence agricultural activities except ploughing. Additionally, managing household chores, child rearing is also the responsibility of the women. The work of tribal women has always been more than their counterparts as they have round annually, unlike men who enjoy seasonal and periodic leisure (Pappala, A.N., 2020).
Data Source and Study Area
For the analysis of women's empowerment, data from the nationally representative Bangladesh Demographic and Health Survey (BDHS), administered by National Institute of Population research and Training (NIPORT) of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare have been utilized. We have used two waves of BDHS data, collected in 2017-18 and 2022 for identifying the changes in women empowerment status and the factors affecting it. These were nationally representative cross-sectional surveys based on a two-stage stratified sample of households. Only ever-married women aged between 15-49 years have been interviewed in these surveys. As the missing values have been eliminated, we were left with 18866 and 18987 observations, respectively.
Covariates and their measurement
The covariates used in the study are age groups, division, type of place of residence, highest education level, religion, relationship to household head, owns a mobile telephone, wealth index combined, currently residing with husband/partner, husband/partner's education level, education gap between husband and wife, media exposure and differences between number of sons and daughters (categorized).
Construction of Women Empowerment Index
Four dimensions of women empowerment have been used to calculate women's empowerment index as there exists no specific concept of women empowerment in the datasets. The survey, however, covered some important dimensions related to it. The dimension “Smoothness to medical facilities” was calculated using four indicators, namely: “getting permission to go for medical facilities”, “Getting money needed for treatment”, “Distance to health facility” and “Not wanting to go alone”. In order to construct the index without a hitch, we recoded the responses of these indicators (i.e. 0 for “big problem”, 1 for “not a big problem” and 2 for “no problem”). The second dimension “Domestic violence” contained five dimensions and was used to ascertain women's attitude towards wife beating. Women's opinion about the justification of their husband beating their wife if “she goes out without telling her husband”, “neglects her children”, “argues with her husband”, “refuses to have sex with him” or “burns the food” were recorded. As this index is negatively correlated with women empowerment, we recorded the responses inversely from the first indicator for analysis purposes (i.e. 1 for “no” and 0 for “yes”. The third dimension “Household decision making” contained four indicators that are defined as: people who usually decides on “respon-dent's health care”, “large household purchases”, “visits to family or relatives” and “what to do with money husband earns”. We recoded the responses as: 0 for “respondent has no role” and 1 for “respondent plays a role”. The final dimension in calculating the index was “Respondent currently working”, which took value 0 if the “respondent was not working” and 1 if the “respondent was working”. A summative index of women empowerment was calculated by taking the sum of the four dimensions. In order to understand the women empowerment index more clearly, we categorized the variable in five categories: completely disempowered for score 0, less disem-powered for score 1, moderately empowered for score 2, highly empowered for score 3 and completely empowered for score 4 or more.
Bivariate Analysis
For examining how the dimensions of women empowerment changes with the change in the covariates throughout the study years, we conducted the measure of association with the Pearson Chi-square test. The hypotheses that need to be tested can be stated as follows:
H_0: No association exists between selected covariate and the dimensions of women empowerment.
vs
H_1: Association exists between selected covariate and the Low Birth Weight.
The following illustrates the definition of the Chi-square test statistic:
Where,
O_ij= The number of observations in the cell (????,) is denoted by i=1,2,⋯,r and
j=1,2,⋯,c.
The expected cell value.
The test statistic follows a Chi-squared distribution with (r − 1)×(c − 1) degrees of freedom. Moreover, the p-value collected from this test is used to make decision.
Ordinal Logistic Regression Model
Ordinal logistic regression model is a statistical analysis method that can be used to model the relationship between an ordinal response variable and one or more explanatory variables, be it continuous or categorical. It can be considered as an extension of logistic regression where the independent variables are linearly related to the logit of a binary response. An important assumption of ordinal logistic regression is the assumption of proportional odds: the effect of an independent variable is constant for each increase in the level of the response. Hence the output of an ordinal logistic regression will contain an intercept for each level of the response except one, and a single slope for each explanatory variable. A cumulative logit parameterization is used in ordinal logistic regression models. However, there are more than one ways in which this can be done. Table 1 shows the parameter-zations used for the cumulative logit model, where J represents the number of levels in the categorical response variable, and p represents the number of explanatory variables. Models 1 and 2 are the most common parameterizations, where the outcome of interest is observing “Y less than or equal to j” where j is one of the ordered categories the response variable.
Table 1: Parameterization models involved in ordinal logistic regression.
There is a direct correspondence between the slope and the ranking in Model 1, as it associates a negative sign. Thus a positive coefficient indicates that the increase in the value of the explanatory variable is positively correlated with the likelihood of a higher ranking.
Ordinal probit model
Suppose that i be the index respondent i, i = 1,…,n, where n is defined as the sample size. Let yi be the response of the ith individual to the survey question, and assume that this can take one of the integer values 1,2,3,…,j. Let be the underlying latent variable that represents the respondent i's inclination of agreeing to the statement advanced. Let xi be a vector of characteristics relevant in explaining the attitude of a respondent. The ordered probit model is based on the assumption that yi* depends linearly on xi, according to
yi*=xiʹβ+µi; where i=1,2,…,n
µi~N(0,1) (1)
b is a vector of parameters that does not contain an intercept. These parameters will ultimately be interpretable in the same way as slope parameters in linear regression. y* is unobserved, but the relationship between y* and the observed variable y is
y=1 if
-¥ < y* < k1
y=2 if k1 < y* < k2
y=3 if k2 < y* < k3
….
y=J if kJ-1 < y* < ¥ (2)
The parameters kj, j=1,…,J-1, are known as "cut-points", or sometimes “threshold parameters”.
As all of the J-1 cut points are free parameters, the intercept of the model specified here is absent. If one of the cut points were normalized to zero, then the intercept parameter would become identified and would appear in the model. The need to normalize either the intercept or one of the cut points, and in addition to set Var(ui)=1 in (1), is in order to set the otherwise arbitrary scale of the latent variable y*. The log-likelihood function shall now be constructed. Suppose that Pi(y) be the probability that the response of the ith respondent is y. This probability is
Pi(y)= P(ky-1 < yi *<ky)= F (ky - xi 'b) -F(ky-1- xi 'b) (3)
Where F(.) is the standard normal cumulative distribution function. So, based on a sample (yi, xi, i=1,…, n), the log-likelihood function is