People around the world have been affected in some way by the coronavirus pandemic. Garo people have been disproportionately impacted by COVID-19, which has had a high impact on their daily lives. The present study was an attempt to explore the impact of covid-19 pandemic in the Garo Community at Madhupur Upazila in Tangail District. Attaining broad objective of the study has also focused on some relevant objectives such as, gathering information about the socio-demographic condition of the Garo people, knowing the psycho-social problem faced by the affected person, observing the psychological conditions of the respondents, knowing the economic condition and gaining broad base knowledge about their lifestyle during Covid time and post-Covid time, to incorporate the recommendation and suggestion to improve their lifestyle and socioeconomic condition in post-Covid time. Our main research approach is Qualitative research and we used the Ethnographic method for collecting information we also used the case study method by using purposive sampling taking five in-depth interviews on the basis of our study objectives. The research shows the actual picture of the Garo community during Covid time. The research found that the Garos have faced great trouble during the worldwide pandemic situation. Most of the Garos are farmers and day laborers, during the lockdown, they lose their work; farmers didnt buy fertilizer and pesticides so their production decreased and they faced an economic crisis, during lockdown they lose their communication system and social isolation which creates loneliness and psychological problem. Due to government instruction, they maintain social isolation and could not perform religious programs, marriage, and other cultural programs limited within the family. They live in a remote place, with no hospital or healthcare facility available there, they suffered a lot of health problems, and Covid positive people did not get enough healthcare support so the death rate was so high.
The Garo (Mandi) Adivasi, is a distinguished matriarchal community of Bangladesh living under challenges to practise their traditional life. Although the population of bangladesh is not as other country of the world, socio-cultural differences exist among the people living here for various reasons. On religious basis, 85% of the population is Muslim, 15% is Hindu, Buddhist and Christian community. Bangladesh is a country of cultural and ethnic diversity, with over 54 indigenous communities, along with the majority of Bengali population. According to the census of 2011, the countrys indigenous population is approximately 1,586,141, which represents 1.8% of the total population of the country.
However, indigenous peoples claim that their population is over three million. Indigenous peoples, with their distinct languages, traditions, cultures, values, and customs, contribute significantly to the rich cultural heritage, ecology, and sustainable development of Bangladesh. But indigenous people are deprived of basic rights and civil services provided by the government mentioned in the constitution. As a result, they are regarded as the very poor, illiterate and backward populations of the country. They are exploited, deprived and survived as marginalized people due to the indifferences of the state and mismanagement of politics. The indigenous people are gradually disappearing because of the deprivation and neglect of socio-economic status, political context, globalization and market economy of Bangladesh. According to the data of several research and reports, this community is con-sidered as the “Marginalized population.” Among them the Garo is one of the largest indigenous communities of Bangladesh. They lives in the north-eastern parts of the country especially, in Gazipur, Mymensingh, Netrokona, Tangail, Sheerpur, Jamalpur and some in Sylhet districts close to the Indian border. There are almost 2,60,000 Garos in Bangladesh, many more Garos live in Meghaloya in Indian side but gaps exist between the government official figures and private estimates (Census Report: 2011). A sample survey of 1979, conducted in Bangladesh found that 20% of Garos do not possess any land, 30% have only a homestead, 30% worked as hired labourers and 20% cultivate mortgaged land (UNDP; SDNP; 2008, P-21). We know most of the indeginious peoples are living in remote areas. In those areas the indigenious people have been living for the long periods of times. Here, the communication system, infrustructure system, helalth facilities and education, other modern equipment are not avilable in those areas. On the others hand majority of indeginius peoples have been dep ending on agricultural production in the ancient times but in covid time in our country most of the place was locked down and no communication and trans portations system was not opened in that times. So, majority of indeginious peoples like Garo people did not sell their productive product and they faced hugh eco-nomics problems in covid time. Majority of the Garos peoples are depend on the traditional treatment systems that they are practing long period of times to cure from diseases. In hilly areas there is absence of modern health facilities and also absence of govt of non govt hospital in those areas. So, in Covid time the Garos people were face lots of problems that impact on physically, mentally, economically and socially of Garos peoples. From an analytical perspective, the investigation intended to find out impact of covid 19 in in-diginious people specially on Garos community and also to recommend some strategies to overcome those challenges from their community in Jalchhatra village under Arankhola union at Madhupur Upazila of Tangail district. Our investigation is helpful to know about the impact of Covid 19 on indigenous people especially on Garo community (Rahman, 2021).
The study focuses on the socio-economic and demographic conditions of the Garo community. It also focuses on their working activities in Covid 19 times and effect the activities of at present after Covid 19 and existing problems faced by Garo community in Covid times and recommendations to solve their problems as well as to preserve their identity.
Statement of the Problem
The Garo is one of the marginalised ethnic minority groups in Bangladesh, originally migrated from Tibet (Bal & Ellen, 1999). They have been living in different areas of Bangladesh for few centuries with mainstream Bengali community. Based on an ethonographic study, the present paper argues that although Garos livelihood patterns are variation from the native peoples because the absence of modernization, urbanization and communication, education, madical facilities are not previlage here. The main research question is to investigate impact covid 19 and also to anlyze the causes of impact on the basis of their life patterns, health, education, income, social aspects.
Over the last centuries, Garos are facing a huge challenges in their normal life. There are a number of problems existing in Garo community such as communication and transportation problem, inadequate education institutions, deficiency of employment and most severely land problem. So, the study aims to investigate and analyse deeply the problem of Garo community faced by during the covid 19. But many other things are also included into this investigation like the economics condition during the Covid times and socail, psychological, health, educational problems faced in covid time and also analysis support from govt and non-govt organization to cope with those problems.
Objectives of the study
The main objective of this research is to know the Impact on Covid19 in indigenous people specially on Garo community, including some other specific objectives which are as follows:
Methodology refers to the theory of the research and the reasons for the way the research has been designed. Methodology explains the research question and why the question is important. It explains the starting point of the research, the directions of the research and the possible implications of the research when it is completed. Methodology explains the literature the researcher is using, the language and terminology, the other theories and explanations being used, the methods and the types of analysis that will be used to interpret the collection data and information.
Location of the Study
There are many ethnic communities dispersedly living in Mymensingh division. They are the Garo and the Hajong. The Garois of majority of them, most of the Garos live in Sherpur, Jamalpur, Tangail, Mymensingh, Gazipur. We conducted our field work in the Garo village named Jalcchatra under the Arankhola union, Madhupur upazila in Tangail district.
Methods of Data Collection
All research has some aim that is why the researcher takes different level of scientific method. Present study is an outcome of short field work that we conducted to Jalcchatra village under Tangail district. In social science ethnography is very unique because it takes in depthinterview, observation, participation, case study etc. Participatory observation and case study were our basic techniques and also did intensive field work. We used other methods, however at first; we built rapport and used method to collect data. Now we are explaining here how we used the method. In order to do the research perfectly, at first, we have to build rapport with the villagers. There were different types of people in the village. So, we arrived and raised many question among them. The villager suspected that we came from a university. For this reason, at the very beginning we declared our aim and introduced our self to them. Then gradually we introduced with all villagers Thus, we could build rapport with the farmers, day laborers, female young girls and children. Then we selected six people by using purposeful sampling for taking case. To collect the actual data, we started case study and in-depth interview with selected six res-pondents.
We observed closely the Garo people of their daily life activities. Rapport building up and observation are very important for qualitative research. Actually, participatory observation and case study were our basic method and we could use this method for building rapport.
Sources of Data
An organized and well-developed checklist has been used in this study which includes the important indicators related to the study. This help the research work to be conducted in a more methodical and systematic way. To know about the impact on covid 19 on Garo community. We also used genealogical method. We have collected data from primary and secondary sources. Primary source is the basic source of the study. The secondary sources are collected from several relevant articles, journals, thesis, and others documents.
Analysis of data
The analysis of qualitative data was completed through several steps such as transcribing the data, interpreting documents and photographs, describing records, verba-tim and the thematic analysis of data. All those steps have been well followed in the study to analyze the primary data which was collected from respondents and field report form case study and participant observations.
Validity and Reliability
Validity of the study explains that the study is true and valid. The honesty and truthfulness both from the research and the respondents ensure the validity of the study (Creswell, 2014). The authenticity of the collected data is indicated by the validity of the study. The findings of the study have revealed the real life based on understanding the livelihood patterns of Garo. Reliability of the study refers to the consistency and dependency of the researcher. Both the researcher and respondents need to understand the importance of the study and feel reliable for the information they share.
Qualitative study means descriptive study where researcher has focused the elaborate idea from the respondents and not using any numerical data. As our study we have used the interview method in our research. It is qualitative research. So, I described the data that we collected on the field in our field work area by using some of term that are related our research objectives. Those terms are:
Poor demographic conditions indicate poor socio-economic structure
Following international institutions and activities nowadays, many states have begun to protect indigenous peoples rights and interests, but in this respect, Bangladesh is still far behind. While talking about the Governments attitude towards the indigenous people in Asia, including Bangladesh, Benedict Kingsbury (1998) mentioned the attitudes of Governments in Asia to the application to their state of the concept of ‘indi-genous people which differ considerably, but strong opposition has been China, India, Bangladesh, Myan-mar and for the most part of Indonesia (Islam & Rafiqul, 2008). In Bangladesh the estimated total population is 15 million of them 98 % of the people are Bengali and predominantly Bengali speaking people. There are 2.5 million indigenous people of 50 different ethnic groups although in different sources the number of indigenous groups differs from between 29 to 65. All these groups mostly have different cul-tures and languages. The Government of Bangladesh does not treat these groups as ‘indigenous people but rather as ethnic minorities. The socio - economic con-dition of Garo community indicated that are very poor. Their socio, economic and educational statuses are not as standard that needed to normal life. They have earned very few moneys that are not suitable to bearing their family life. For economic problem they have not fullfil their basic needs.
Majority of Garo people are involved in agricultural work and their main occupation is farmer. They have no any opportunities to join others occupation because in that area people have not got any support to join others occupation.
Lack of the health, communications facilities makes them backwards community
Health and communication facilities are most important criteria for any of community development. But, it is matter of sorrow that the communication and health facilities in Garo areas are not developed as compare to need based. There is no modern hospital in Garo areas and peoples do not get modern treatment for curing their disease. Basically, majority of Garo follow traditional treatment method for curing their diseases. We saw that there is no numerous hospital in our research area and we also saw that majority of peoples goes to kabiraz or oja for curing their disease. We also astonished to see that majority of Garos now practicing traditional healing practice for curing disease. The communication facilities of my research area are not overall development. Majority of road pass into the hill and muddy. Peoples cannot go easily in town area at any emergency needs.
Analysis Lack of health, communications facilities make them backwards community
The health and communication facilities in Garos area are not developed. In modern time, there is no modern equipment related hospital are not existing in research area. People are suffering a lot of problem for the lack of communication and health facilities.
Poor education conditions focus on less awareness about present world
Education is very in every person life. Without education no one gain higher position in their career. Bangladesh is developing country and most of the people live below the poverty. Education problem has become a global problem in our country. Education creates awareness among the people. It is the very important to any one life. Its what helps us adapt and grow. Napoleon Bonaparte said that, "Give me an educated mother, I shall promise you the birth of a civilized, educated nation", today to know the present world education must be needed. To development any nation and create awareness education facilities should be ensuring.
Analysis Poor education conditions focus on less awareness about present world
To better ones life education must be needed. An uneducated population is in great burden in any nation. Literacy rate in Bangladesh is now 74.66 percent, according to the preliminary report of "Population and Housing Census 2022". But in study area the educational status is very low and people are not aware to education. There are no numerous educational institutions here that is main barrier to improve educational condition among the peoples.
Confined themselves in household at Covid time make their life be different
There are so many deaths in the country of Corona. The procession has a great impact on the lives of individuals and society, they live in hardship. Days are spent starving and panicked
No opportunity to perform normal life as usually they do in normal activity
Conduct technical training to develop them as skilled human resources. Providing various agricultural products and training Garo women in various handicrafts so that they are financially well off. Helping them with various agricultural inputs and agricultural improvement techniques. Garos can be developed as a working class of the country if their work is resourced and initiatives are taken in various ways then the country will develop.
Need go and NGOs support in for developing their conditions
Garos are suffering from various problems like health food water education etc. They are unaware of various social issues such as child marriage. Water problems and unsanitary conditions make life difficult. If go and various NGOs come forward, their society will be saved from these bad situations. They will be aware of their rights. Among them is the biggest problem. The local Bengali dominant group wants to occupy their lands. If go and various NGOs come forward against this, then they will be saved from extinction from society.
Income generating program and different types of instruments for developing their life after Covid
Garos are generally looked down upon by Bengalis in various ways. They are looked down upon in various activities and opportunities in the society. Depriving them of their right to action. Depriving them of various fair rights. They want to live like normal Bengalis. They are not a separate group. Bengalis want to live as a nation.
No opportunity to perform cultural and social Program in Covid time
In covid time there was no opportunity to perform Cultural and social program. Also included Religious Program. The Covid-19 pandemic had a sudden and substantial impact on the cultural programs Cultural activities are sports or activities which contribute to or enhance the history on social development, appreciation of members of the public. Some cultural programs are celebrating the festival, Charity events, Sports events, visiting national park, Join the heritage tours and Dance and music competition and soon. Some social activities are food assistance, housing subscription health insurance and on. During Covid time no one can perform those activities because of maintaining social distance.
Social isolation creating a lot of psychological problems and mental problem in Covid time
In covid time, there is a high cost associated with the essential quarantine and social distancing intervention for covid-19, especially in older adults who have experienced an acute, severe sense of social isolation and loneliness with potentially serious mental and physical health consequences. Social isolation or loneliness is associated with various psychological and mental repercussions, including elevated systolic blood pressure and increased risk for heart disease.
No Administrative supports in Covid time has created lots of problems
The Garo Community is of the marginalized community in Bangladesh. Covid 19 has a great impact on this community. As already isolated from the world, they became more isolated during Corona. People of this community become very helpless due to lack of sufficient work specially in covid time. They had to go through financial crisis as they could not sell their agricultural products on time.
The Garo community is very dependent on nature. They are very superstitious. They followed their conventional treatment during Corona. Many people in this community still do not believe about the corona virus.
There was a considerable lack of administration to en-sure corona vaccination. Education sector is the worst affected during Corona. Many children dropped out as school was closed.
Garo community mostly depends on agriculture. They cultivate puddy, pine apple, lemon, bananas etc.
Women were more vulnerable and assumed by husband in covid time
Women are more vulnerable group in every community. But in Garo community women are respected. Women have to work hard all day long in the field. Women are much assiduous than men. During Covid 19, the women of Garo community had to go many difficulties. As the family income was less, there were quarrels and disputes in the family.
In this research, most of the people age is about 40-55 and some of them belong to 44-46. It is also found that most of them are unemployed and depend on subsistence farming work to bear their life expenses. Also, most of the people are engaged in farming and some of them are day laborer, businessman and job holders and others are engaged in different occupations. Data shows that a large number of respondents belong to lower and middle class family. In this study, it is found that large amounts of the people in Garo community are very helpless. They did not get any facility from the government in Covid 19 situation. In their community many of the people are unaware about nutrition as a result they suffer from various disease. Their main problem the owner of the land. The land which they lived this land is not yet registries by their name. However, normally they are facing very much problem in this situation. It is a clear observation that economic condition has a great impact on Garo community according to most of the respondents. Majority of the respondents do not have any saving. Ensure self-determination rights of the Indigenous Peoples of Bangladesh in the spirit of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. It is also found that most of the people are uneducated. In order to maintain the continuity of school during the lockdown, the government took the initiative to broadcast classes through a public television channel (Sangsad TV). The class contents were also uploaded on YouTube to help continue the curriculum amid the closure. However, due to the existing digital divide, many children and youth living in remote areas of the Garo community are deprived of accessing remote learning initiatives of the government. This is also the same for poor indigenous children in the plain land. They are unknown about their right. In covid 19 situation they have to remain home they did not continue their daily earning work for this their income was very low. Loss of livelihood and income.
They did not take proper food at a time. In this study, we find that most of the people have good relation with their family; relatives and friends but they did not celebrate any kind of festival because of Covid 19. It very bad time for them. We also find that due to covid 19 times they did not get proper market price of their farming product. A number of facts are also responsible for this condition such as they are not known about new technology. In garo community people should be educated otherwise their community development is impossible. Governments help must be en-sured them and ensure their proper legal right. Medical facilities are very poor in their community. Garo needs special support and special care in that time because of living remote areas. They are very helpless people. In any vulnerable time, government should be provided.
For development their community education must be need. Without education any community not to be developed. They have to introduce about new modern technology. They have to know modern agricultural system and deny the traditional agricultural system.
Their sanitation knowledge was very low. They did not know the proper sanitation system as a result it impacts very much on their health. On the other hand, they have lack of the nutrition knowledge. They did know how to cook to proper way. Ensure timely distribution of information materials in indigenous languages, adequate food, economic support, safety kit assistance for the marginalized indigenous peoples. Ensure access to healthcare services for indigenous communities during the lockdown. They have to provide sustained, long-term economic relief for the marginalized Indigenous Peoples of Bangladesh such as universal access to public services and universal social protection through specialized programs.
Garos have to live with many problems which include land problems, water problems, sanitation problems, education problems etc. The nature-loving Garos have to fight constantly to sustain their existence. Apart from agriculture, fishing was their main livelihood. Earlier they used to earn their livelihood by fishing in the canals, now they have to depend on agriculture. While the Garos of the plains are engaged in various occupations. The Garos are left behind because they are looked upon differently by the people of the plains. One of their problems is the land problem which always bothers them. Without proper steps of the government to solve these problems, socio-economic development is not possible. The corona epidemic has affected them a lot. The loans taken at high interest rates during the corona period have become a major problem in their livelihood. The government and various NGOs should come forward to solve these problems.
Recommendations
People of Garo community had faced many problems during the covid 19. Most of the family members cant communicate with their relatives and cant buy their agriculture goods in market and they cant perform properly in their duty. Preparedness is the key to dealing with any health crisis. There are many recommendations which help the Garo people to solve the various their problems. Food supply needs to be made accessible to remote tribal areas such as Garo areas through government and various NGOs. They also need to formulate and implement sound plans to improve the quality of our social, economic and educational infrastructure so that every of Garo people will get proper education and others facilities. For ensuring quality health facilities they need lot of modern equipment furnished hospital and E- based services so that every of Garo Peoples will get health facilities easily. We know that most of Garo people are basically dependent on Agricultural based occupation but need to arrangement of micro credit for Garo low-income people so that they will have got opportunities to join different types of occupation. Increasing education rate among those areas need to priority and implement Small scale scholarships programs that should be provided to all Garo students to increase their interest in studies. To elimination social problems we have to priority strong social connection among the Garo communities so that they can solutions their problems by using discussions each others. Most of indigenous peoples live in remote areas in Bangladesh and those areas have not good communication and infra-structure in those areas. We everybody know that any development in any communities firstly we have to priority communication and infrastructure development otherwise our development will be vain. So, we must be creating good communication in Garo areas so that the Garo peoples will easily communicate others people. We also used SWOT approach for solu-tion the Garo community problems in their community.
I would like to express my profound gratitude to Most. Ummay Hani Kulsum, Lecturer, Department of Social Work, Bangamata Sheikh Fojilatunnesa Mujib Science and Technology University, Sumaya Tahsin Hamida, Lecturer, Department of Sociology, Begum Rokeya University, Bangladesh, Bangladesh, Md. Bipul Reja, Lecturer, Department of Social work, Gurudayal Govt. College. Kishoreganj and Dr. Md, Al mamun Sarker, Assistant Professor, Department of Social Work, Bangamata Sheikh Fojilatunnesa Mujib Science and Technology University, Bangladesh for their incessant facilition and encouragement Throughout the research.
The author and coauthors announced that there are no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research work.
UniversePG does not own the copyrights to Supplemental Material that may be linked to, or accessed through, an article. The authors have granted UniversePG a non-exclusive, worldwide license to publish the Supplemental Material files. Please contact the corresponding author directly for reuse.
Academic Editor
Dr. Sonjoy Bishwas, Executive, Universe Publishing Group (UniversePG), California, USA
Department of Social work, Bangamata Sheikh Fojilatunnesa Mujib Science & Technology University, Jamalpur-2012
Kabir I, Kulsum MUH, Hamida ST, Reja MB, and Sarker MAM. (2023). Covid-19 and its impact on indigenous peoples: an ethnographic study on Garo community at Tangail district, Br. J. Arts Humanit., 5(2), 51-60. https://doi.org/10.34104/bjah.023051060